I have a 2014 JK. When it was new, I bought the Mopar floor slush mats (rubber), and those held up for about 5-6 years. After that, my heel wore through that rubber, and it leaked into the carpet below. Got these Bestop mats a few weeks ago and I like them. They are a harder and taller material than the Mopar, so it felt different for the first few days. They installed easily and fit reasonably well. As others have said, there is a space on the side of the mat that does not fit well against the side of the vehicle. But other than that, they seem to be a good fit. No issues with the clutch, brake, or gas pedals. These seem like they will last longer than the rubber Mopar mats.